Tags
abuse, blogging, churchians, culture, faith, insanitybytes22, opinion, politics
Does the religious right even write poetry? Asking for a fellow blogger who suggests that, No, they do not write poetry because one cannot make poetry out of sheer vitriol.
Bahahah! Oh ouch, methinks she nailed it. Chuckling here because one of the definitions of “vitriol” is, “sulphuric acid, or one of many of its compounds, which in certain states have a glassy appearance.”
I used to call a lot of people within Western Christianity, “the beautiful people.” It wasn’t a compliment, it meant the cup was all shiny on the outside, but the inside was just a glassy acid of pure vitriol.
Keep following me for more handy tips on how to win friends and influence people.
So I refer you to Aaron Renn’s article at First Things called, “THE THREE WORLDS OF EVANGELICALISM.” It is about the shifts in our culture, the culture wars and culture warriors, and how 2014 to the present is the 3rd phase, the time when “Society has come to have a negative view of Christianity.”
Praise the Lord, I have always lived in this world! I mean that sincerely. I bring good news, it is the best place of all to be! I’m telling you, I’ve had to really fight for my faith. That means knowing what you believe and why it matters and learning to depend exclusively on Jesus.
Thank God, “Society has come to have a negative view of Christianity.” Maybe now we can all begin to focus on what’s really important?
I don’t particularly like all the Christian social media influencers, the movers and shakers within mega churches, the hierarchies, jockeying for position, churchian politics, constant denominational schisms, or competing for political power and social approval. I think that for far too long, many Christians in the Western world have approached faith in terms of climbing the corporate ladder, checking the Christian box because it looks good on their resume. Going through the motions because it may benefit us socially and politically.
Actually, I really despise all that. I want to see something authentic and real. Intimacy with Jesus! I’m a little bit older than many “nones” of today, those claiming to be religiously unaffiliated, but I can so relate to being sick and tired of the politics, fed up with the celebrity preaching, tired of the private jets and McMansions, fed up with the whole celebrity churchian culture and jockeying for status.
Reading Renn’s articles (and a few others responding to it) something that really jumped out at me, there is no mention of Jesus anywhere in our discussions of evangelism. No talk about love for our neighbor or personal growth. The motivation is just about more power, politics, and building a brand. It’s so, so corporate. Also, filled with lots of big words and frequent celebrity name dropping.
Renn also speaks of President Trump, of how that created farther divisions, how “a man of such low and boorish character horrified some people of a generally conservative disposition who might otherwise have remained part of the religious right.” Ha! True, but the Bible reminds us, “Thou art that man, David!” I am delighted to align myself with those of a “low and boorish character. ” I hope none of us decide to just live there, deplorable forever, but we all come to Christ with a “low and boorish character” and move towards becoming a new creature.
What bothers me is that some of us among a Christian conservative persuasion are so elitist, so self righteous, so clean and shiny on the outside that we don’t even realize we are also, “low and boorish.”
Renn says, “Some of this change represents overdue reform: For example, some evangelical institutions have indeed failed to prevent or properly respond to accusations of sexual abuse, such as those against Ravi Zacharias.“
Oh, you don’t say? Speaking of low and boorish characters! I suspect he has no idea how huge that is, how significant, how important. Like, Ravi was held up, admired, protected, sheltered, and defended for years simply because he was the CEO of a ministry brand. People were heavily invested in making sure he stayed shiny on the outside, by silencing anyone seeking justice, or simply seeking an acknowledgment that they might matter, too.
Ravi, like so, so many others, left a whole lot of collateral damage strewn about. The church at large, overall, doesn’t even recognize that collateral damage as a real thing.
See the, problem is and always has been that it doesn’t matter what you do, it’s who you know, how many people are invested in helping you maintain your power and status. How many bottom feeders do you support? People who have watched these scandals fall out of the church have received the message loud and clear, you don’t matter.
Protecting the brand is always going to be more important then protecting me.
Speaking of “you don’t matter” narratives, few people will hear me. In fact, I’m not even really invited to the table to discuss the future of evangelism. I’m off in the backwoods of my blog, eating bugs and honey with wild hair, speaking tough truths no one really wants to hear.
Renn speaks of the “rise of the nones,” one third or more of people with no professed religion who “may be unfamiliar with Christianity and find it quite odd or even offensive.”
Au contraire, one third of the people are very familiar with Western Christianity and simply do not like what we see. I’ve never met a “deconstructing” Christian or an unaffiliated “none,” who wasn’t dealing with massive amounts of unhealed trauma, mostly around covered up and unacknowledged sexual abuse and domestic violence.
Make them matter. Jesus did. Jesus does.
There is no collective group called the religious right, I don’t think. There isn’t even a collective western Christianity. There are quite literally thousands of Protestant denominations and numerous Catholics that have both eastern and western under one hierarchy. But all of that is corporate church. Hirelings. We need them, but they aren’t the savior we’re supposed to be following. Being that Jesus talked about hirelings letting us down in the Bible, I know this issue isn’t confined to western Christianity. It’s a problem with humans in authority in churches everywhere. We just happen to have a lot of comfort, while Vietnamese churches, for example, struggle just to exist. That doesn’t mean they don’t have problems with their church authorities, though. I would like to talk about the poetry problem on my blog, or this comment will be too long…
LikeLiked by 4 people
Ha! I would love to read about your poetry problem.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Please talk about that problem ! Sounds interesting.
My blog also addresses the rumored Death of Poetry…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I just posted it. Will the link-back show up?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Not sure why the link-back didn’t show up, but great post! Here’s a link for those who might want it.
https://jilldomschot.wordpress.com/2022/01/20/does-the-left-even-do-poetry/
LikeLiked by 1 person
I.B, you and Jill Domschot restored my sanity today.
Thank you both for blogging words of truth, faith, and reason.
This is a worthy post. My only disappointment: you got me all interested in an exploration of poetry on the Right, but then you veered off into other relevant topics and left me hanging. I am a (saved) ex-Anarcho-commie Leftist, so I guess maybe I could be called Religious Right, although I am a very bad Calvinist and still kind of a dissident. Actually, I guess I am more Sworn-to-Fun-Loyal-to-None as Churchianity goes . . .
But I DO write poetry, think about poetry, and I am very interested in the Poetry Wars.
I invite people here to visit and sample my wares:
https://connecthook.net/tag/poetry-sucks/
https://connecthook.net/mine/
In fact, I.B, what I try to do is exactly what you said at the onset; I do my best to make poetry out of my vengeful vitriol.
Check some of my National Poetry-writing pages (NaPoWriMo 8 years in a row !) if you feel lyrically inclined.
Thanks again.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you for your kind words. I am glad you have found Jill’s post. You are indeed, a poet! Sorry I left you a bit confused with this post.There really is a relationship between the religious right and a lack of poetry and I’ll try to expand on that theme some more at another time. 😊
LikeLike
The whole vitriol in poetry is a lost art. I’m glad to see it resurface. Poets used to dish out both political and personal vitriol in verse. Poetry wars, I guess. Those were good days. The problem with memes and Twitter rants is they aren’t composed of heroic couplets.
LikeLiked by 2 people
(good days for poetry, I mean)
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thought-provoking post, IB. I think the discussion hinges on the definition of “religious right.” I think some people confuse politically right with religious right. There may be some intersection, but politically right includes a lot of people, some who don’t even call themselves Christians. On the other hand, some that might identify as conservative in their views about the Bible and Jesus and salvation, would not consider themselves politically right. Then there are the false teachers who are in it to win it, who desire power over the kingdom they have created, who use religion for their own purposes.
And there are some, like Ravi, who fell into the very sin he preached against. He is by no means alone. But he reminds me of King David. God ordained his work, and he was good at leading his nation, but he slid slowly into sexual sin (acquiring the many wives God told him not to take) until he committed adultery and murder. It’s tragic. Yet God called David a man after His own heart. How? I guess because he was a man—a human being with a sin nature. But repentant and forgiven.
As for the poetry, interestingly the morning host on the radio station I tune into in the morning has started reading some poems various local pastors have written. She never solicited them to my knowledge, but apparently they are sending them to her. I also thought that much of the poetry of the “religious right” comes in the form of song lyrics. Some of the best, I think, from Keith Getty and his writers. In case people aren’t familiar, check out “In Christ Alone,” which was one of his first, and best.
Becky
LikeLiked by 3 people
I love your take on King David, becky. I think we could even call him a “right wing poet.” There are some beautiful lamentations and Psalms from the heart.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What made David a “man after God’s own heart” was the fact that he owned up to his sin … eventually. When Nathan confronted him, he could have had Nathan executed – he was the King, after all. But he immediately confessed, repented, wrote a psalm (51) pouring out his guilt and need for forgiveness for all to see. And when after being forgiven by the Lord the consequences of that sin came anyway, I don’t recall his ever complaining or blaming anyone else. He continued to throw himself on the mercy of God, which fortunately is a huge target. That’s far different from the defensive attitudes we see so often with “Christian celebrities” these days, who may preach repentance but seldom show us examples.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s a good point about David and repentance. The defensive attitudes, the arrogance and hostility, within a bunch of modern Christian celebrity culture, really does rub me all wrong.
One of my favorite explanations for, “why was David a man after God’s own heart,” is because he literally was chasing after God’s heart. It makes me laugh because sometimes we complicate things, overthink, and miss the obvious. So if any of us would like to become a “man after God’s own heart,” simply go chase after God’s heart.
LikeLiked by 1 person
many churchgoing people I knew growing up looked down on the artists and most musicians…now they wonder why they couldnt find people to make paintings and play decent music on Sundays.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Right!? That’s it exactly. I’m being a bit snarky about why the right can’t write poetry, but that’s a real question from a blogger who has observed the same, lots of looking down on artists and muscians.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Where I lived, the “right” turned away from “art”, which is what was done correctly in Europe where my people were from. Much of the artistic world is considered “faggy” now. It is like it had been ceded away and no one has a concept now. (We have forgotten the LVBs, JSBs, and the Klimts).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, I remember that, too! The “right” was very down on art. I think that mindset really contributed to the situation we are finding ourselves in today. It’s weird because today it is the “left” tearing down statues and vandalizing public art, even abusing musical instruments! I’m from a place in time where people held things like guitars and violins in reverence and so it was completely unthinkable to vandalize one.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hard, necessary truths, Gabrielle. So keep on eating those bugs and honey, you with your wild hair, and speaking those tough truths no one really wants to hear!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Mitch. 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Some day I may write and publish the complete story of my separation from churchian/denominational/worldly Christianity and my marooned yet vibrant spiritual life in the Church and in the Lord (but severed from the politics of the Church). Like other commenters, I agree that no monolithic “religious right” exists in the United States. That label has been created by secularists and the mainstream media to marginalize Christians in the political world. I must agree with you on this, though: nothing could be better for the true Church in the United States than to be mocked, opposed, and ridiculed… because now we can share the suffering of Christ and also share in his glory. J.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great comment, Salvageable. I would love to hear your story someday! And a big amen to being, “mocked, opposed, and ridiculed… because now we can share the suffering of Christ and also share in his glory.”
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m on a mission to write some poems of sheer vitriol now.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Ha! That is an intriguing idea.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Reblogged this on clydeherrin.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, Clyde. Much appreciated. 🙂
LikeLike
Pingback: Moar Poetry…. | See, there's this thing called biology...